In Which I Compare Death Metal to Shakespeare

A glaring omission from the list of topics that I have provided my unwanted opinions on so far is that of music. For a large part this is because metal is a huge staple of my musical diet, and it’s hard to explain to someone what the appeal is if they simply don’t get it (more on the linguistic aspect of this later). Reviews, for example, often take it for granted that the audience is familiar with the artist, or at least the genre, and write based on that assumption. However, my goals are more ambitious: to explain to an audience unfamiliar with metal (or whatever sub-genre of metal tickles my fancy at any given time) what it’s about and, importantly, why someone might voluntarily subject their ears to such a racket for any extended period of time.

Just your average extreme metal fans.

So I’ve decided to take this as a challenge; the plan is to try to explain some genres I enjoy and precisely what I enjoy about them. Whilst I don’t expect everyone who reads this to immediately jump on Amazon and order the entire Darkthrone back-catalogue as a result, I would hope that at least it might help someone who doesn’t share my tastes understand what the appeal is for those that do. I’ve decided to begin with a genre that’s probably not too familiar to the uninitiated: melodic technical death metal. What in God’s name is melodic technical death metal when it’s at home, I hear you ask. Melodic technical death metal (you might have guessed) combines elements of both technical and melodic death metal, fusing technicality with melody, brutality with finesse. In order to understand why someone might get their kicks from this sort of full-frontal sonic assault it seems like a good idea to focus on a case-study.

In decreasing order of hyperbolic content and increasing order of plausibility, here are some claims about the song “A Diamond for Disease” by Arsis:

  1. It is the greatest metal song ever written.
  2. It is the greatest death metal song ever written.
  3. It is the greatest melodic death metal song ever written.
  4. It is the greatest melodic technical death metal song ever written.

I hope to be able to convince you of the last two of these points at the very least. Let’s see if my powers of persuasion can get us any further up the list.

The unusual background to this song is fairly well known to fans of the genre, since it was written for the Ballet Deviare, a New York City dance company that choreographs modern ballet to metal. They asked for a 15-minute epic for the main piece of one of their shows, and this is what Arsis gave them. It took the guitarist and lead vocalist James Malone around four months to write and the result is nothing short of one of the greatest pieces of extreme music ever constructed. The song is so epic and complex that there aren’t enough members in their normal live lineup nor enough time to play the full version, so they play a distilled version that clocks in at 1/3 of the total time of the original and with one less guitar.

Buy this EP. Now.

Let’s walk through the track step-by-step. Consider this a listen-along guide for people to whom metal simply sounds like a bunch of loud instruments falling down some stairs; the blog equivalent of a Tate Modern audio guide explaining what that funny-looking blotch on the side of a dead cow is supposed to represent. If you still don’t get it by the end then I fear that technical melo-death is just not for you, dear reader! However, crack on the song, give it a chance, and if I actually convince anyone of the worth of the genre be kind and let me know in the comments.

A Diamond for Disease:

[00:00-01:02] The band takes a full minute to build up to the main onslaught, introducing a key motif that resurfaces throughout the song in the process. Mike van Dyne is already showing off his drumming talent at this point with some fantastic fills. A typical element of melodic death metal is the use of two or more guitar parts both contributing towards the same melody, either by means of harmonisation or by splitting one riff between two guitars. The latter is a favourite of James Malone’s, especially for rhythm sections, and he sets the mood for what is to follow by carving the intro riff up into two and alternating from one guitar to another for each successive note in the melody, reflecting musically the internal conflict that lies at the heart of the song.

[01:03-01:39] This is where it begins to get technical. The guitars synchronise for the main muted riff, splitting at the end and riffing off each other in an alternating pattern, as before, but this time at a blistering speed. We hear Malone’s vocals for the first time and he manages to maintain reasonably good diction given that he’s screaming down a microphone, clear enough anyway for him to introduce the lyrical themes for the song; deception, broken promises and betrayal–“Denial! (your death was promised!) of the thoughts our feelings dissolve! Chosen wisely, disguising all intent. Amidst the poetry, I thought I heard you say…”

[01:40-01:54] “Oooooh, let’s make a deal!.. A diamond for disease! Oh, Christ! It’s a betrayal!.. A diamond for disease..” We have a hook! I bet you weren’t expecting that when you were told that you’d be listening to some melodic technical death metal. Malone introduces what I’d probably call a chorus if the song wasn’t a meandering 13-minute long metal extravaganza. Trust me, you’ll be humming it to yourself later.

[02:10-03:29] Here we get the reintroduction of the first muted riff, this time serving as the rhythm for the first solo. This is followed by a breakdown and a section where the guitars largely take a back seat, first so that Malone can let the vocals take centre-stage to develop the details of his depressing wedding story: “Your words, spoken in the guise of an oath; the promise of never. Now never is all I ever receive; never, and the knowledge of your disease! Your words spoken aloud, ‘I do’, the promise of never..” Of special note is the last few seconds before the chorus kicks back in, since it’s the first time that three guitars can clearly be heard; two leads harmonising the same furious melody and the rhythm supporting them. The layering of three guitars generally stays for the rest of the song, reverting back to a single lead and rhythm towards the end when things start to calm down a bit.

[03:30-04:34] Worthy of note in this section is the fact that the song is still adding in more and more layers of complexity. The previous three or four riffs are now being brought in and mixed up far more frequently. Even the chorus section, ostensibly the same as it was when first introduced, now includes new harmonies breaking off from the main riff to complement it. All of this adds to this thickness and depth of the song and the frequency with which the third guitar follows its own distinct lines creates a sense of momentum and progression even where riffs reoccur and motifs are repeated.

[05:20-08:45] Quite simply, this is the most awe-inspiring few minutes of any metal song I’ve had the good fortune to hear. Let me break it down:

[05:20-05:36] The first part of this section serves masterfully to set up what is to follow. The two lead guitars somehow manage to harmonise whilst both playing a blisteringly fast, relentless, beast of a riff, creating a wall of noise that fills every inch of audial head-space. This is juxtaposed with the drums and the remaining guitar, which hammer home a precise, military-like rhythm that drives the song forward through an unnecessarily torturous number of bars waiting for the release. Throughout this the vocals follow the same repetition of ‘I never knew!’ until finally the barrage relents and breaks out in to…

[05:37-06:07] ‘How loose! You used! The word! Friend!.. In time I learned, a diamond for disease!’ At this point all hell has broken loose on the guitars. We have the reintroduction of the motif established right back at the beginning of the song taking its sweet time on one lead, the other is continuing the brutal sweep-picking-cum-tapping-cum-shredding barrage from the last part and underneath that, since apparently this wasn’t enough, is a rhythm line giving some chops to the main motif.

[06:39-06:55] This section is enough to make your head spin. Not only are we treated to more of Malone’s love for alternating rhythm riffs between headphones (and guitars), but now he decides to extend the same courtesy to the vocals. The result is close to having Malone himself surround you, justifying himself and screaming accusations–“I (can) not (for-) GIVE!.. [Both:] but only you know the truth!”–doubling up the vocals where necessary to fill in the texture somewhat.

[06:56-07:26] If the three layers of guitars have so far blended into one mass of technical metal glory, the solos that occupy this section should make it abundantly clear just how much work is going into harmonising and coordinating their efforts. The part during which all other instruments and vocals cease genuinely makes my hairs stand on end. If you still don’t get it by this point then I’m afraid we’re speaking different languages.

[07:43-08:45] This section is fantastic as an illustration of how the vocals and instrumentation complement each other. It begins with a solid, clear riff in which all three guitars play in unison–“Yet I still come, like a moth to a flame in assurance of pain…”–Slowly harmonies creep in and the leads split off to do their own thing, throwing in the odd rogue lick, tearing apart the coherence of the starting rhythm–“And still she comes, a breathing deathwish, with daggers drawn.”–Then the muted riffs burst in, the drums explode–“Denial! (Your death was promised!) of the thoughts that our feelings dissolve!”–Until finally all structure and solidity collapses into a dual shredfest underpinned by a gatling double-bass, a wall of noise and chaos–“Your secrets, they follow, and shadows always show.. the path to the fallen, that’s gone away! Take your skin away!.. Wield the liar’s dagger!”

The result is akin to a death metal pastiche of soliloquies from King Lear and Macbeth. Following King Lear, Malone’s narrator reflects on the betrayal that he has suffered as a result of a misjudgement of character of those close to him, gradually loosening his grip on sanity. The developing storm that reaches its raging peak at the height of Lear’s insanity is replaced by the onslaught of thunderous instrumentation, mirroring the narrator’s descent into madness. Like Macbeth, however, he is haunted by the spectre of daggers, and his madness takes a murderous turn.

[08:46-10:07] The chaos continues in much the same way for the next minute and a half, both musically and lyrically, tearing riffs and lyrics from the past 8 minutes, combining and recombining them in new patterns, colliding them together with ferocious intensity. With the exception of a break for another short solo, things continue this way until the track begins its wind-down to the relative calm with which it began.

[10:07-12:52] Finally, the riffs and motifs from the first two minutes are reintroduced and reworked and taken apart until the song fades out on a melancholy note.

And fin.

(Oh, and my tendency to “deconstruct and analyse pretty much everything I come into contact with” that I mentioned in my last post? I think it just happened.)


One thought on “In Which I Compare Death Metal to Shakespeare

  1. Pingback: Thick Aesthetic Concepts in Extreme Metal | CTRLtomDEL

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s